12°c Overcast
24°c Cloudy with showers
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Obama torn by conflicting allies
TEL AVIV -- U.S. President Barack Obama has shown once again how difficult it is for him to navigate among four of his closest allies regarding Syria and Iran.
Israel and Saudi Arabia are pushing for a harsher reaction to Iran's continuing drive to acquire nuclear capability. At the same time, they are urging harsher steps against Syria.
In contrast, Turkey and Qatar argue that a military strike against Iran at this time would be "disastrous."
After a week of Israeli threats against Iran, Obama sought to lower tempers Sunday by calling for restraint and arguing in a TV interview that economic sanctions are working.
Obama also discreetly counselled Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to "calm down" bellicose cabinet ministers. Netanyahu obliged, ordering his ministers to refrain from comments about Iran and its atomic programs.
The warlike rhetoric about Iran last week was "accidental" and totally unnecessary. Addressing the Herzliyah Conference, the most prestigious security and policy forum in Israel (attended by Canadian Foreign Minister John Baird), Deputy Prime Minister Moshe Yaalon, Defence Minister Ehud Barak, Chief of General Staff Gen. Benny Gantz and Chief of Military Intelligence Gen. Aviv Kochavi reviewed the strategic challenges facing Israel in 2012.
The reviews were serious and wide-ranging. The four spoke of the Arab Spring and its implications for Israel. They addressed the massacres in Syria and predicted that Bashar Assad's days are "numbered." And they spoke about Iran and its dangers.
This last point received the widest media coverage. The consequent fuss was unintended and totally unnecessary. I attended the conference and heard U.S. Ambassador to Israel Dan Shapiro tell the forum that "the American and Israeli positions regarding Iran are fully co-ordinated."
He added that both countries believe the economic sanctions against Iran "are working," but added, "all options remain on the table."
It was exactly the same position pronounced Sunday by Obama.
It is obvious both the U.S. and Israel are giving preference, for now, to diplomacy and economic sanctions.
Nevertheless, it would be wrong to separate the Iranian problem from that of Syria. The U.S. and its allies knew Russia and China would veto the Arab League draft resolution at the UN Security Council. It was clear that just as Russia does not want to lose its only base in the Arab world, neither does Iran. But Russia does want Assad to reform his regime, a message Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov is carrying to Damascus today.
Iran, too, does not want to lose its Syrian base, with its extension to Lebanon via Hezbollah. But Iran is encountering financial difficulties in helping Syria. Iran sent a small contingent of its Revolutionary Guards to help suppress the rebellion in Damascus, but because of sanctions it lacks the financial means to help Syria quell the rebellion. In other words, Iran has begun to feel the effects of sanctions -- if not in Tehran, certainly in Damascus.
It is here where the U.S. is facing a dilemma. Israel, Saudi Arabia and other Persian Gulf countries want the U.S. to apply more economic pressure to Iran to reduce its ability to interfere in Syria. They argue that Assad's downfall will change the dynamics in the whole region.
Without Iran's presence in Damascus, its links to Lebanon's Hezbollah will become meaningless. Iran's huge investment in arms, training and financial support will go down the drain. This, in turn, would reduce Hezbollah's ability to dictate Lebanon's foreign policy and could return Lebanon to the western camp.
Turkey does not contradict this scenario and sees the benefits in ending Iran's presence in Damascus and Beirut. But Turkey also has economic interests to protect. Turkey does not want to lose its economic ties to Tehran and did not accept the loss of its economic ties to Syria. Turkey is now the headquarters of the Free Syrian Army and maintains a close relationship with the population in the Idlib region of northern Syria.
Turkey also realizes that the end of Iran's presence in Syria and Lebanon is likely to strengthen Israel's strategic position in the entire "Fertile Crescent" -- Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Iraq. Such an outcome is unacceptable to Ankara, especially because of the unresolved conflict with Israel over the Mavi Marmara ship.
It is between these two conflicting trends that American diplomacy is now navigating.
Samuel Segev is the Winnipeg Free
Press Middle East correspondent.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition February 7, 2012 A10
More Columnists
- Back to Top
- Return to Columnists
Poll
Proudly brought to you by:
Most Popular Columnists
- Good things come in small packages
- Jets could be greatly affected by deal
- Shy, kind and soft-spoken -- with the power to infuriate
- For Tim's mother, the issue is safety
- Rob Lowe shooting Casey Anthony story here
- Chelsea hungrier than Bayern
- Lobbyists' political gifts come at a price
- Vocal valour
- Snowbirds, Americans living in Canada read on...
- You could've warned them that you were leaving
- Common courtesy decreasingly common
- Some can't afford humane thing to do
- Jets could be greatly affected by deal
- Good things come in small packages
- For Tim's mother, the issue is safety
- Shy, kind and soft-spoken -- with the power to infuriate
- Best to use old stadium for entire season?
- Real NHL battle could just be about to warm up
- Bro: move in; you: move on
- Doomed water park gave Katz watershed moment
- If we build it, look out
- Common courtesy decreasingly common
- Majumder surprisingly frank -- and funny -- in HBO special
- You've got a Target? We're in
- Empty inside
- Katz versus Ford
- Can't share a vision when no one asks
- Some can't afford humane thing to do
- Water-park decision will show world who we are
- Signing Pav, completing stadium top of mind
- Long haul 'family' Every employee is a spoke in the wheel at Bison Transport
- Try cheese toast, caesar dressing at Like Hy's
- Jets could be greatly affected by deal
- Play's the thing to catch conscience of Parliament
- Common courtesy decreasingly common
- Becoming a hairstylist today goes far beyond knowing your way around a pair of scissors
- Some can't afford humane thing to do
- Long haul 'family' Every employee is a spoke in the wheel at Bison Transport
- Shy, kind and soft-spoken -- with the power to infuriate
- Try cheese toast, caesar dressing at Like Hy's
- Hope turns to dust in Niger
- Floating feline 18-year-old cat loves family swimming pool
- Rob Lowe shooting Casey Anthony story here
- Signing Pav, completing stadium top of mind
- You've got a Target? We're in
- Alberta vote is a gift for Harper
- The birth of a banana republic
- Rail firm looks to grain
- Play's the thing to catch conscience of Parliament
- Hope turns to dust in Niger
- The prince and the paper
- 'A special kind of sad'
- Another fine snow job from 'open' government
“We need to carefully add all the diverse elements that people need to live in a place: restaurants, workplaces, nice residences, perception of safety, green space, convenient transport, nearby schools for the kids they would like to have - if any piece is missing, the outcome will not last long.”
Posted by: goldenbob
Article: A SHED is not enough
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010; View the changes. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.